Ryan Marin
“America is a nation of immigrants.” It’s a phrase that has been used to discuss our country for many years, and one that many Americans say with pride. The statement is also factually true, as we currently have 44.5 million immigrants residing in the United States. When you account for their U.S-born children it rises to 89.4 million people, or 28% of our population (Migration Policy Institute, 2018).
Immigration has shaped America by introducing us to other cultures, more specifically the Latin culture. We have picked up many things, such as their language, food, and their best athletes. They also provide substantial benefits for the United States economically. Sadly, America has taken advantage of this, as we have stolen many of those ideas and customs for our benefit, while hurting the people who brought them to us in the first place. While we are doing this, we are beginning to see immigrants who have overcome increasingly difficult obstacles and challenges to speak on the issues facing them and their people. This is helping them get involved with the political process, and allows immigrants to tell their stories from their point of view.
America has picked up many things from the Latin culture. According to the PEW research center (2013), “With 37 million speakers, Spanish is by far the most spoken non-English language in the U.S. today. The number of [Spanish] speakers [is] up 233% since 1980, when there were 11 million Spanish speakers”. Two years of a foreign language class is now required to go to many colleges and universities in the United States, and the most common language taken is Spanish. It has become increasingly important and beneficial to speak multiple languages as America now has a significant Hispanic population of 59.9 million, up from 47.8 million in 2008 (PEW, 2013). America has also become fond of latin cuisine, as hispanic style fast food chains have spiked in popularity. According to QSR Magazine (2018), Taco Bell has become the fifth most lucrative food chain in America, with Chipotle clocking in at twelfth. We’ve even taken many of their best athletes for our sports, such as in the MLB, where many of the best players in the game immigrate from latin countries. They are discovered as children and teens and go to training academies and work on baseball year round, and eventually go to the minor and major leagues if they are good enough. Many have become stars of the game, such as Javier Baez, Carlos Correa, Jose Altuve, and many others.
While we have gained many cultural benefits from immigration, immigration also provides massive economic benefits for the United States. First, as American citizens become older and retire, we have to figure some way to keep the workforce young and pay for services in the social safety net such as social security and medicare. Immigration is often a large part of a solution to this problem. Immigrants come here and enter the workforce, unable to access America’s social safety net, while paying taxes such as the payroll tax that helps fund social security and medicare. According to the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, over 75 years “ the fiscal impacts of immigrants are generally positive at the federal level and generally negative at the state and local level.” Immigrants give the federal government more in taxes than they receive in benefits, but at the state and local level they receive more benefits than they pay in taxes due to their native born children going to school. America benefits substantially from immigration, and it is one of the reasons that they are a global power.
While all this may benefit Americans, it is troubling to me is that we often steal from these people and countries and make it our own, actively hurting them in the process. More people are speaking spanish than ever before in America, but when someone who looks hispanic begins to speak spanish, we get angry and tell them to go back to their country. We enjoy spanish food, but instead of supporting small businesses that make authentic latin cuisine. We go to places such as Taco Bell and Chipotle, gigantic corporations with a white CEO who pays poverty wages to their employees, many of whom are people of color and immigrants. In baseball, we take the best athletes from Central and South America, many of them poor teenagers, and pay them extremely low wages for over ten years. As soon as they aren’t profitable and we have no use for them anymore, we send them back to their impoverished countries without a second thought. When we discuss immigrants in the workforce, we believe that they work for little pay to reduce wages for natural born citizens, that they take advantage of the government and the social safety net, and that they commit massive amounts of crimes. In reality, they do the jobs that Americans do not want to do because we feel that we are too good for those jobs, and essentially better than immigrants. Immigrants also pay into the social service system while receiving very little from it and contribute to keeping our workforce young. Most importantly, immigrants commit fewer crimes than native born citizens, despite the right wing media exclaiming the opposite. But even if all of those things were the opposite, and they did not provide a huge economic or cultural boost, we have a moral obligation as a country to be welcoming of people all throughout the world. Immigrants deserve human rights and decency, as they are humans as well, and those who deny it simply have evil in their hearts. We are supposed to be a country where anything is possible, a country of hope and opportunity, but for immigrants it often times is a country of oppression, racism, and false promises. Luckily, more and more immigrants have been able to break through and become part of mainstream American culture, and we have been able to hear a unique perspective on immigration that we have not often heard before: the perspective of the person immigrating to this country.
Until recently, we have lacked representation from latin countries. For so long we have not given these people a voice, as we are often exploiting them and want to continue to do so. We have seen our country slowly allow immigrants and latin americans to enter the mainstream, particularly in music. Today, some of our most popular musicians are immigrants or descendants of immigrants from latin america. Cardi B, an extremely popular musician from New York, is black with a Dominican and Trinidadian ethnicity. What makes Cardi B special is that she is outspoken about her political affiliation, as she is an avid Bernie Sanders supporter. She recently had a sitdown meeting with him to discuss issues such as healthcare and immigration. The importance of this cannot be understated. In America, our young people are extremely disconnected from the political process. They are struggling to get by and are doing worse than generations before them. Sadly, their response is to simply tune out politics, which in effect is only worsening their situations. Cardi B understands this, and is using her voice to influence her followers to get involved politically and learn about the ways that America is rigged against them. As many of her supporters are Black and Latin women, this is extremely important, as they are often the people who are most affected by harmful immigration and labor laws. Rihanna, arguably the biggest pop star in the world, is from Barbados. While she is an extremely successful musician and businesswoman, she consistently speaks out against the treatment and demonization of immigrants in America. She often discusses Donald Trump and his horrible immigration policies, and offers a unique perspective on immigration due to being an immigrant herself. “Wherever I go, except for Barbados, I’m an immigrant. But I think it’s important for people to remember, if you love me, everyone out here is just like me. A million Rihannas out there, getting treated like dirt” (Cut, 2019). The power in those words is undeniable. Until recently, immigrants have lacked representation and people that can speak on issues surrounding immigrants and their treatment in America. Providing a voice for those who have been voiceless for so long in mainstream American culture is extremely important. It gives Americans a new perspective on how America treats its immigrants that we didn’t have before, and allows immigrants to speak about the injustices they have faced in this country.
We are a country that is proud of its diversity, but only when it is beneficial to us. One day, we will begin to make amends for all the harm that we have done to these people, but with the current person in office, I do not see that happening anytime soon. So instead of making amends for our sins, we will continue to demonize and fearmonger immigrants, despite everything they do for our country.
Sources:
https://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/immigrants-have-enriched-american-culture-enhanced-our-influence-world
U.S. Hispanic population reached new high in 2018, but growth has slowed
https://www.livescience.com/28945-american-culture.html
https://www.thecut.com/2019/06/rihanna-takes-a-stand-for-immigrants.html
https://www.qsrmagazine.com/content/americas-25-most-lucrative-fast-food-chains
https://www.migrationpolicy.org/article/frequently-requested-statistics-immigrants-and-immigration-united-states#Children
https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2013/08/america-the-continent-vs-america-the-country.html